Do Not Harden Your Heart Against the Poor
The Inner Command — Torah Legislation of the Heart
Deuteronomy 15:7: “You shall not harden your heart, nor shut your hand from your poor brother.” The verse contains two prohibitions and one positive command (the positive command — “you shall open your hand” — appears in Deuteronomy 15:8). Commandment #490 addresses the first prohibition: the hardened heart. This is remarkable legislation. The Torah is not merely saying “give to the poor” — it is forbidding the inner posture of emotional closure from which the failure to give flows.
The verb “te’ametz” (you shall harden) comes from the root meaning to be strong, firm, resistant. A hardened heart is a heart that has made itself firm against the natural impulse of compassion — a heart that has trained itself to see poverty and feel nothing. The Torah prohibits this training. Compassion when confronted with suffering is a natural human response; the deliberate suppression of that response in the face of a fellow Israelite’s poverty is a covenant violation. The Torah does not merely commend a generous spirit — it commands it.
Brother — The Relational Frame of the Charitable Obligation
The verse says “your poor brother (achi-kha ha-evyon).” The Torah does not say “the poor person” in the abstract but “your brother” in the specific relational sense. Israel is a covenantal family; the poor Israelite within your community is not a stranger but a kinsman. The hardening of the heart against a kinsman’s poverty is qualitatively different from indifference to a stranger’s suffering — it violates the relational bond that defines the covenant community.
This relational framing elevates the charitable obligation beyond mere generosity or social policy. It is a family obligation: you do not abandon a family member in need. Leviticus 19:18: “You shall love your neighbor as yourself.” The “neighbor” and “brother” of these commandments are the members of the same covenantal household — and toward household members, indifference is not an option. The poor brother is not a social problem to be managed; he is a family member to be helped. The heart that hardens against his poverty has forgotten what family means.
The Approaching Shemitah — Hardening the Heart in the Sixth Year
Deuteronomy 15:9: “Take care lest there be an unworthy thought in your heart and you say, ‘The seventh year, the year of release is near,’ and your eye look grudgingly on your poor brother, and you give him nothing, and he cry to the LORD against you, and you be guilty of sin.” The Torah anticipates a specific temptation: as the Shemitah approaches, the lender calculates that any loan made in the sixth year will be cancelled by the debt-release and refuses to lend. This calculation — economic rationality in the face of another’s poverty — is the “unworthy thought in your heart” that the Torah explicitly condemns.
The prohibition on hardening the heart is thus not merely a general exhortation to empathy but a specific regulation against the kind of calculating closure that finds economic justifications for refusing compassion. The Torah acknowledges that the hardened heart usually has reasons — the Shemitah is coming, I can’t afford it, he brought it on himself, others will help. All these rationalizations are forms of the hardened heart. The Torah says: do not harden your heart. Open your hand. Give.
Read the source passage in the Torah reader.
Read in the Torah Reader