Do Not Sell Land in Israel Permanently
The Land Is Mine — Divine Ownership and Human Tenancy
Leviticus 25:23: “The land shall not be sold in perpetuity, for the land is mine; for you are strangers and live as foreigners with me.” Three clauses, each essential: (1) no permanent sale; (2) the ground of this prohibition is divine ownership; (3) the implication of divine ownership is that all human possessors of the land are guests. The Israelite who farms the Land of Israel is not its owner in the ultimate sense — he is a sojourner, a tenant, a steward. God is the landlord; the tribal land distribution is the allocation of tenancy rights; and these tenancy rights cannot be permanently alienated because the landlord has reserved the right to restore them.
This is the theological foundation of the entire Jubilee and Shemitah system. The Shemitah returns the land to its natural state for one year in seven (Leviticus 25:2). The Jubilee returns ancestral holdings to their original tribal owners every fifty years (Leviticus 25:10). Both rest on the same foundational claim: the land is God’s, and God has structured the land’s tenure to reflect this. No human decision — however desperate, however commercially advantageous — can permanently override God’s ownership of the land.
Price and Years — What Is Actually Sold
Leviticus 25:15: “According to the number of years after the Jubilee, you shall buy from your neighbor, and according to the number of years for crops he shall sell to you.” The price of a land sale in Israel is a function of time. If many years remain until the Jubilee, the land is worth more — many harvests remain before the return. If few years remain, it is worth less. What the seller is actually selling is a lease on the land’s harvests for the remaining years until Jubilee. The land itself remains God’s and, through the tribal distribution, the seller’s ancestral inheritance.
This system has profound economic implications. Land accumulation — the concentration of land ownership through purchase — is structurally limited. No matter how much wealth a person accumulates or how many land parcels he purchases, all those purchases expire at the Jubilee. Economic power built on land cannot be permanently concentrated across generations; the Jubilee decentralizes it every fifty years. The prophet Micah condemns those who “covet fields and seize them, and houses, and take them away” (Micah 2:2) — a condemnation that reflects the covenant framework in which Jubilee is supposed to prevent exactly such permanent accumulation.
Strangers and Sojourners — The Theology of Human Land Tenure
“You are strangers and live as foreigners with me.” The Torah uses two words: “gerim” (strangers, resident aliens) and “toshavim” (sojourners, temporary residents). These are terms the Torah uses for non-Israelites who live among the people of Israel. Here they are applied to Israel itself — in relationship to God. Just as a resident alien in an Israelite city lives there by permission and within the framework of his host community’s laws, so Israel lives on God’s land by permission and within the framework of God’s ownership.
This is a radically humbling theology of land tenure. The Land of Israel — the covenant land, the land of promise, the land flowing with milk and honey — is not Israel’s to do with as it pleases. Israel is a tenant on God’s land. The covenant gave Israel access to the land and distributed it among the tribes; but access is not ownership. The prohibition on permanent land sale enforces this: no human transaction can permanently alienate land from the structure God has created for it. The land is on loan.
Read the source passage in the Torah reader.
Read in the Torah Reader